Update on the Ron Ficathon...

[icarus]

I am soooooo not into this story *drudgery, drudgery* and it is very, very dull.

Very dull. I apologise in advance for inflicting this story on the fandom.

*heavy sigh*

Wow, this sucks. I'm not exaggerating, it's lifeless.

*Icarus does CPR*
*Then kicks fic*
It doesn't even twitch.

I hate het.

Comments

[sarka.livejournal.com]

Is this an argument?

Nope, it's not. Just a curious question, from someone who doesn't understand her friends when they wail about how the slashers did this and the het shippers did that, and so forth. I like/read/write both and sometimes I feel like I'm a total minority. I'm just wondering whether that's true.

Miss Pince.

[icarusancalion.livejournal.com]

I dunno. I know that when fanfiction and NC-17 fanfiction is railed against, slash tends to be singled out. So I think that's created an artifical dividing line that really doesn't make sense if you think about it carefully.

The 'slashers' have had to band together to preserve and protect their work, and it's created a tight community that the Het writers haven't needed to form.

Het and Gen writers are welcome, but it's like a non-smoker hanging out with the smokers: you always feel a little on the outside.

Most of the slash writers I know read all of it though, Het, Gen, Slash you name it.

The only complaint I have about Het really, is that it lends itself to Mary Sues. You find many, many more Mary Sues in Het than you do in Slash. I assume this is because there are so many teenage girls writing fanfiction and they identify with a particular female character. So I read Het with Much Trepidation. I generally only read Het stories that have been recommended for fear of what I might find.

Icarus

[sarka.livejournal.com]

This is interesting. I'd never thought about it like that. See, this is why I asked you. I knew you'd come up with an answer :)

Miss Pince.

P.S. I'm sorry if I sounded like I was trying to start an argument at first. English is my fourth language and sometimes it doesn't come out quite the way I want it to... and I end up saying something totally different from what I mean.

[icarusancalion.livejournal.com]

Damn, my loooong answer yesterday didn't post. I think I was all argumented out (ha, I should copyright that phrase) from something else that was going in LJ.

Anyhow, I've almost finished the Ron Ficathon piece (19 pages in and I just have to write the final scene), and now I'm trying to track down a ruthless beta. Most of my stuff in the past has come out fairly finished in the first draft, but this one is very rough and I know it.

But I managed to stick very closely to Mags request: it is Quidditch and plot-centric. It is about corruption in Quidditch. The only real pairing is Ron/Hermione, and while their relationship is central to the story, this is not one of my porn stories. It may be a little darker, more angsty and more romantic than she planned, because what got my interest was the moral dilemmas the situation suggested.

Icarus

[sarka.livejournal.com]

Well, congrats on getting the story done. I'm having trouble getting into mine. (The "Where do I start?" dilemma.)

Anyway, if you need the sort of beta who goes; "Uh... don't think he'd do that..." or someone who's well versed in R/Hr, I can do that. I'm good at spelling as well but grammar and punctuation kick my arse. As for wording, I can usually tell if there's something wrong with it, but not what it is... I'm not sure if I'm a ruthless beta, though. Not unless I'm expressively told to be nasty. Just thought I'd offer :)

Miss Pince.

[icarusancalion.livejournal.com]

Hi, thanks! I've asked tinderblast and ygrane to beta, but thanks for offering.

Characterisation's probably not the issue, though I'm sure I describe Ron and Hermione's relationship differently than anything else out there, as I've never even read Ron/Hermione.

I'm going to withhold judgement on the story and wait for what they have to say.

Icarus