Annnnd the winner is... the favourite Icarus story.

[icarus]

Normally I praise the author here, but I think I'll skip that and go straight to the battle. Primer took an early lead with its opposition clearly split by the determination that BMFI and Death Eater Rock counted as separate fics. But in the end -

Beg Me For It

...scraped into the lead, with 15 1/2 votes. Welcome to the dark side.

This gives me hope for the democratic party.

Second place tied was not a tie (whoops, misread) with
Primer to the Dark Arts with 14 1/2 votes
Sex, Drugs and Death Eater Rock and 9 10 1/2 votes. Because my credibility is sunk anyway, I'll add your vote lyricalnights.

Sorry, that scratch out really did look like another set of five hash marks.

Skinny Dipping garnered 4 votes.
Zen Taxi the newcomer surprised us with 3 votes.
A Moment Of Sin gathered 3 votes.
Sweet Hypocrisy got 1 1/2.
An Irresistible Photo received 1 as well.

Also rans...
Hagrid's Hut
Your Friendly Neighborhood Death Eater
Ron/Teaspoon but the management believes mctabby was kidding.

The fine print:
Previous votes are McTabby, Um, Icarus *eheh*, Anna, Minx, Maya, Amanuensis, Rushlight, Sushi, Aspen, Cybele, and Cassandra Claire. Void where prohibited.

Comments

[notuilion.livejournal.com]

Somehow, I don't know how, I'd managed to read as much as I have in the fandom without reading any of Beg Me For It until this week. Maybe I heard the name so many times I just came to assume I'd read it? Horrible, horrible oversight on my part. Stayed up hours past my bedtime.

Am mostly incoherent with fondness for the whole thing. It seems my love of Shattered is unique though, so what's left of my mind has its say here (http://www.livejournal.com/users/icarusancalion/69031.html?view=1435815#t1435815) (linked in case you don't read comments to historical entries).